leadforensics

Different Product Configuration Approaches

  • CAD
  • PLM
  • Blogs
  • SLM
  • Sort by type
  • Products
  • Technologies
  • myPDS Apps
Published on
2019-03-12
Written by
Perttu Korpela

PDS Creo ConfiguratorProduct Configurators gives companies a possibility to manage product variants in an efficient way, for PTC Creo Parametric, we use myPDS Configurator, but more about that later.

You hear often people talking about product configurators as a solution to quite different and sometimes even conflicting needs. Whereas configurator gives a company a possibility to manage product variability in an efficient way, this should not be confused with product portfolio management.

Configurators are used to generate a unique product structure for a specific order or quote without the need to create and maintain all possible product variants.

In many cases a product may have hundreds of thousands possible variants but only fraction of possible variants is ever sold or quoted. Naturally companies do not want to spend money in creating and maintaining documentation for structures that are never going to be built.

Do you have a few products but a million product variants?

The different configurator requirements and solution can roughly be divided to three categories:

  • Sales Configurator, also known as Configure Price Quote (CPQ)

    • Focused in creating quotation documentation including pricing efficiently. Sales and pricing rules are often very different compared to rules used to create physical product structure.
  • BOM Configurator

    • Focused in creating engineering or manufacturing BOM efficiently. Need to be able to create a complete BOM and use very sophisticated configuration rules.
  • Design Automate

    • For complex, and many times one-off product deliveries, there are number of design deliverable’s that need to be created. Design automats are focused in automating the deliverable creation. Automation can lead many times to significant design time savings.

Different configuration approaches – ATO – CTO – ETO

When listening people talking about different configuration approaches, you might hear ATO, CTO or ETO acronyms. The definition of them is not always 100% clear and my explanation here might differ slightly from someone else’s explanation.

Assemble to Order (ATO)

This configurator type might be the easiest one to understand. Here a unique product configuration is created by combining existing product options (or modules). Normally options are kept in stock and configuration is created when an order requiring specific combination is received. Only top-level item is created as new variant collecting the options. There is very little engineering needed and no order specific documentation created apart from Bill of Material.

Most common way is to create so-called super-BOM (or 150% BOM) that collects all product options into one structure. The order specific structure is created using choice logic to select or filter the combination of options needed in specific order.

Configure to Order

Difference between configure to order and assemble to order processes is little vague. It can be said that Configure to Order process can create more order specific variants than just top-level item. Top-level product structure can have variant children that have been created by combining options under them. Still there is no need to create order specific manufacturing documents or product visualizations. All the options have been pre-validated to be compatible by engineering when creating the super-BOM.

Engineer to Order

Some say that Engineer to Order is not a configuration process at all. It is used for deliveries where significant number of new items, and sometimes even new options, need to be created to fulfil the order. And in a way this is true. But this domain has big engineering time saving potential, if the product architecture and design tools support configuration.

Design automats can automate creation of design deliverable and save hundreds of design hours per delivery project.

When to use a configurator?

Creating a configurator is an investment and takes most of the time more time and resources than anticipated. Because of this, a company should evaluate following things before starting a configurator:

  • What is the number of potential product variants, if all them would be created?
  • What is the configuration approach, ATO, CTO or ETO?
  • For ETO, what is the number of design hours spent in creating documents for one variant?
  • For ETO, what is the anticipated order volume for each product being analyzed?
  • Is it a competitive advantage to be able to deliver products that meet customer requirements through configuration?

Implementing configurator or design automat to ETO process requires typically product to be redesigned to support configuration. It should be realised that typically it is not feasible to try to be able to create all possible variants with a configurator. 80-90% production volume target for a configurator is many times best that should be expected. Trying to reach higher level of automation will either lead into too strict product structure that does not allow needed flexibility or will cost too much to be economically justified.

Finally

Finally, I would like to mention few technical capabilities that should be evaluated when choosing a configurator solution:

    • What is the requirement for component individuals? Can different component occurrence have different rules applied to itself when placed to a parent?
    • What deliverables should be created as part of the configuration process? Typically, configurators can create 3D models easier than manufacturing drawings and like.
    • For CTO and ETO products, the design automat should also be able to add components to a parent and not only remove unneeded options. In best case the whole model and drawing should be possible to create from scratch. For complex and large products, it is not feasible to create an assembly holding all possible options.

 

Best Regards
Perttu Korpela

Social media

Follow us on our social media platforms


RELATED BLOG POSTS

PTC Creo 10 is here

Creo 10 is here with a wide variety of improvements to help make every day more productiveThese include......
Read more

Connected products extend the digital thread

Digital Thread PDSVISION supports manufacturing companies in their digital transformation by enabling the......
Read more

Leaving Information Island

Democratizing information is a cornerstone for a successful Digital TransformationIn projects that aim to......
Read more

Mathcad Prime 9

Solve your most complex problems with the new and improved Mathcad Prime 9 Mathcad Prime 9 has finally......
Read more

The undoubted benefits of implementing a PDM system

For any product development company, the PDM System (Product Data Management) is an essential component as it......
Read more

PDSFORUM – An event that inspires digital transformation

An event that inspires digital transformation Every step in the value chain — from product engineering to......
Read more

Creo combined with Ansys Mechanical – Your Competitive Advantage In Product Design

The challenge of designing winning products is getting more difficult by the day. The choices made in the......
Read more

KeyShot 11.3 for Apple Silicon – Speed Gains and Improved Performance

Keyshot 11.3 is the latest version of Luxion's powerful 3D rendering and animation software designed for......
Read more

Materials make the world go round

The meaning of the word “material” conjures up different ideas for different people. For some, the look......
Read more

Contextual Data for IoT

Meaning of data from IoT sources If you have ever read Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy, you would know......
Read more

Using Functional Safety and Reliability for a competitive advantage

Functional Safety and Reliability is a hot topic that stimulates many discussions, depending on the......
Read more

PDSVISION and Renholmen extend their collaboration

Thoroughness drives innovation, and no detail is insignificant. Work hard to make the customers satisfied and......
Read more

Getting Started with IoT for Manufacturing

“In the beginning … the earth was formless and empty.”  – Genesis Where to begin? That is a good......
Read more

What’s new in Luxion’s Keyshot 11.2?

Keyshot 11.2! This version offers a range of powerful new features that allow users to create stunning......
Read more

PDSVISION and PTC have together helped further Electrolux Professional’s digital transformation

As a highly profitable, customer-centric business trusted by over half of Europe’s Michelin-star......
Read more

PTC Creo 9 is here – Available via PDSVISION

Creo 9  has landed with a range of updates, new features, and options designed to significantly accelerate......
Read more

PTC Creo 9 – What’s New?

There has been an addition to the PTC family of Design Solutions; PTC Creo 9 has arrived! PTC Creo 9.0 is......
Read more

Compliance within MedTech and the medical device industry

Today's product development faces several challenges, and one of the biggest challenges is regulatory......
Read more

Accelerate digitization with myPDS applications

PDSVISION launches 9 powerful applications to accelerate digitization in the manufacturing......
Read more

Short facts about KeyShot version 11.1

This version includes several new features and improvements that will make creating amazing visuals faster......
Read more

Getting Vuforia Engine setup in Unity in 2022

Vuforia Engine is a software development kit (SDK) for creating Augmented Reality apps. Developers can......
Read more

Integrate ECAD with PLM to achieve full product definition

As PLM Business Director, I meet with companies from different industries daily. It is apparent that all......
Read more

KeyShot 11 – Now Available!

The world of visualization infinitely expanded with KeyShot 11 – now available via PDSVISION KeyShot 11 is......
Read more

Enterprise Visualization in the Product and Service Lifecycle Business – one unified automated publication pipeline

As part of digital transformation roadmaps, industrial companies explore enterprise visualization to enhance......
Read more

10 useful Creo Parametric features you should be using in 2022

One of the reasons why Creo Parametric has grown in popularity among engineers is due to the software’s......
Read more

Professional Windchill Training: What can you expect?

Enhance your skills in PTC Windchill PTC Windchill training is the most effective way to build your......
Read more

Professional Mathcad Training: What can you expect?

Engineering calculations for everyone - in PTC Mathcad One of the main advantages of Mathcad over its......
Read more

Professional Creo Training: What can you expect?

Accelerate your skills in PTC Creo This blog post briefly explains what you should expect when coming on a......
Read more

Professional KeyShot Training: What can you expect?

KeyShot training to accelerate creation of amazing photo-renderings and animations KeyShot training is......
Read more

Who needs Creo? – A look into the capabilities and benefits of Creo

Three great news in Creo 8.0 Anyone interested in 3D CAD and specifically product design should look no......
Read more

Factors to consider when choosing a CAD system

Choosing a CAD system is an important and potentially daunting business decision. In this article I will go......
Read more

Creo for entrepreneurs and Start-Ups

The optimal way to jumpstart your business Starting a new business is an exciting and challenging time –......
Read more

BOM Management: Defining your digital products

Why is BoM Management important? Accurately managing the holistic bill of materials (BoM) across fragmented......
Read more

Industry 4.0: Transforming Manufacturing In The UK 2021

What is Industry 4.0? Allowing your business to transform its manufacturing means that that you're allowing......
Read more

Reduce CO2 emissions/environmental footprint with Augmented Reality/Vuforia

Reducing our environmental footprint with Augmented Reality and Vuforia A hot topic for many businesses are......
Read more

The Best Industrial Augmented Reality Platform

What is Vuforia? Vuforia is PTC's enterprise-level Augmented Reality (AR) product suite and one of the best......
Read more

Importance of a Digital Transformation strategy

Research from IDC states that ‘‘The demand for Digital Transformation is coming from customers and......
Read more

Experts in product and packaging design company Noun chooses KeyShot and PDSVISION

Noun is a design studio based in Stockholm, Sweden, that specializes in product and packaging design. Noun......
Read more

ANSYS Discovery – Introduction

After long and sunny summer, the fall starts to kick in. Now is the time to get geared up for the winter’s......
Read more

How is Augmented Reality Changing Engineering?

Augmented Reality In Engineering Everything we do in engineering - before we actually make anything - tends......
Read more

Vuforia Instruct – Complementing PTC’s Industrial AR solutions suite!

  Vuforia, the award-winning and leading Augmented Reality reality solution-centric......
Read more

The Handyman and The Gentleman – AR #7 – Vuforia Work Instructions

To continue discussing how relevant Augmented Reality (AR) is for the industrial enterprise, in this blog, I......
Read more

What is the ‘’Internet of Things (IoT)’’, and why is it important?

Connect products, facilities and people with IoT The phrase internet of things or IoT is thrown around a......
Read more

Digital Transformation is happening – Don’t get left behind

Digital transformation is here, and it will affect everything we do. Digital transformation is happening –......
Read more

Working on our ways of working – to support our customer projects in a better way

At PDSVISION we strive to be the best at what we do, and we have always been proud of our deliveries and our......
Read more

PTC Creo 8 – What’s New?

There has been an addition to the PTC family of Design Solutions, PTC Creo 8 has arrived! When an update to......
Read more

The Handyman and The Gentleman – AR #6 – Capture, Edit & Author

In my previous blogs, I have shown and discussed how the PTC Vuforia family of solutions is becoming the......
Read more

OnDosis chooses PDSVISION on their journey into improving healthcare

OnDosis develops products used for flexible and individualized dosing of oral medicines for diseases with a......
Read more

Mathcad Prime 7.0 is here!

PTC have released the seventh version of the Mathcad Prime calculation software which includes a range of......
Read more

The Handyman and The Gentleman – AR #5 – Vuforia Expert Capture – Simple, Secure and Smart

In this blog, the fifth in my series based around my Augmented Reality video series "The Handyman and The......
Read more

The Handyman and The Gentleman – AR #4 – Vuforia Expert Capture

I’ve spoken recently in blogs on how AR applications (Augmented Reality) such as PTC Vuforia Chalk can......
Read more

Creo Parametric Behavioral Modeling Extension

Design automation for various design goals with PTC Creo Parametric Behavioral Modeling Extension......
Read more

PTC’s Vuforia – Top 5 use cases

Our top 5 Vuforia use cases from our experts In this post our very own Vuforia Experts here at PDSVISION......
Read more

The Handyman and The Gentleman – AR #3 – Working Hands Free

In my previous blog I explored with you how such a simple task as an onsite customer maintenance task or......
Read more

The Handyman and the Christmas StARs

"How can Augmented Reality come to my aid as I face my biggest challenge since joining PDSVISION?Making......
Read more

The Handyman and The Gentleman – AR #2 Problem Resolution

All business’ understand the importance of getting the work done correctly and to standard the first time.......
Read more

Keyshot 10 – Now Available

Keyshot 10 is here and available via PDSVISION. KeyShot 10 brings unbound creative capability to help realise......
Read more

Trimble AB Invest In Luxion Keyshot

[caption id="attachment_10854" align="alignleft" width="300"] Image: Trimble[/caption] Luxion KeyShot is the......
Read more

The Handyman and The Gentleman – AR #1 – Getting Work Done

Imagine you’re a Field Technician, sent out to a customer to perform scheduled customer maintenance.......
Read more

Ambulansproduktion and PDSVISION continue their joint journey!

Ambulansproduktion develops the markets most innovative and robust ambulances. These ambulances create safety......
Read more

Energy Machines and PDSVISION initiate collaboration!

Energy Machines and PDSVISION started collaboration around both CAD and PLM components, last week. This with......
Read more

Before you can really consider AR and VR, you need to get the conversation going!

Before you can really consider if AR and VR will have a beneficial impact on your business, you need to get......
Read more

PTC Creo Parametric ( Pro/ENGINEER) vs. Solidworks – The Second Coming

Hello, do not worry, I am not intending to discuss with you W. B. Yeat's famous poem from 1919 today! No, I......
Read more

How do I create a single part in the context of the assembly in PTC Creo Parametric?

For historical reasons, PDSVISION Germany has many customers who use Creo Elements / Direct Modelling.......
Read more

AR – Meeting the Industrial Enterprise needs in manufacturing

My clients ask, "How can AR make our production staff and manufacturing process more efficient?" Is there a......
Read more

The Need of Digital Twins to Support Circular Economy

PDSVISION has recently participated in the EU Commission funded Horizon 2020 project studying circular......
Read more

Whats new in PTC Creo 7.0?

Here in Finland, Spring returns and brings new sprouts from the ground, leaves to trees and endless sunshine......
Read more

PTC Creo vs SOLIDWORKS

Rivalry between Creo vs SolidWorks. As a senior consultant for PDSVISION I spend a lot of time with......
Read more

Getting things done remotely, in a world that almost changed overnight

Vuforia Chalk - The solution to the collaboration challenges we face within 3d design With people’s......
Read more

Ansys – More Than Just Simulation

We at PDSVISION have supplied solutions around Ansys portfolio of products for some years, especially Ansys......
Read more

5 Reasons to invest in KeyShot

Create 3D renderings, animations and interactive visuals. KeyShot is Luxions globally known stand-alone......
Read more

PDSFORUM – time well invested

PDSFORUM – time well invested"4.5 out of 5 in the score for our workshops" Participant survey"The most......
Read more

Delivering value with Augmented Reality

A conference room filled to the breaking point was the scenario when we hosted a breakfast seminar together......
Read more

Getting started with PTC Creo Simulation Live now easier than ever!

PTC Creo Simulation Live is one of the first results to come form the partnership between PTC and Ansys. It......
Read more

BoM Transformation – Product Lifecycle Data is Created in Engineering

[caption id="attachment_7471" align="alignright" width="300"] BoM Management in PTC......
Read more

Change Management – A Cornerstone

"….most design is a variation from or modification to, an already existing product or machine".(Cross,......
Read more

PTC Creo – The best CAD software on the market today

Religion, politics, what football team you cheer for, some topics can generate emotions instantly when......
Read more

Creating Inheritance Models for Manufacturing with Creo Parametric (Formerly Pro/ENGINEER)

In design, the question often arises as to how you can design so that you do not have any problems later on,......
Read more

The benefits of using myPDS Configurator

I find PTC Creo Parametric as an excellent 3D CAD solution for large, configurable assemblies. Creo......
Read more

Windchill 11.1 – PLM in the modern web

Windchill 11.0 has been around for the last two years. With its release PTC started a journey to renew the......
Read more

Creo 5.0 Update

The PTC Creo 5.0 release is jam packed with new features, Topology optimization studies, built in flow......
Read more

Saving Heat Treatment Steps Means Saving Costs

Cut manufacturing costs with MAGMASoft Many of our customers ask me if we can help them to cut manufacturing......
Read more

3D printing with Creo Parametric

3D printing or, a bit more technically phrased, Additive Manufacturing, may be on everyone’s lips and......
Read more

myPDS Apps – What problem do they solve?

PDSVISION has been developing for years add-on solutions for PTC software users. I am regularly asked why are......
Read more

Security in PTC Windchill – Part 2 of 2

In my last post on the theme security in Windchill I provided some general tips for creating a safer server......
Read more

Great features in Creo Simulate

Some hints on existing functionality that one might not be so familiar with and some features from Creo......
Read more

XML – DITA, DocBook, S1000D or Shipdex – Are you confused?

More and more, technical writers are realizing the value of XML as a format to use for their document......
Read more

Security in PLM System Windchill – Part 1 of 2

Security is something we often seem to take for granted. The problem with this is when something goes wrong,......
Read more

Take Control of your Creo Parametric modeling

Many companies are continuously expanding their utilization of 3D CAD. Both for manufacturing material but......
Read more

Five tips from our Support

Our Support team helps our customers worldwide with our solutions, Creo (3D CAD), Windchill (PLM), Simulation......
Read more

Life as a Support Engineer at PDSVISION Support

Working as a support engineer at PDSVISION Support is a varied job and no day is like the other as you get to......
Read more

11 great improvements in Windchill 11 – Part 2 of 2

PTC Windchill 11 was launched 15th of November, the top highlights - Top down support of Find Numbers......
Read more

What is your IoT strategy?

Business leaders are today aware of the potential of the Internet of Things (IoT) to fundamentally change......
Read more

11 great improvements in Windchill 11 – Part 1 of 2

This is part 1 of my Windchill blog review of the improvements in PTC Windchill 11.0 (PTC Windchill PDMLink),......
Read more